Going Paperless: The Possibilities that Moodle Offers
Tuesday, February 24th, 2009Contributed by Thomas S. Dickinson, FITS Faculty Coordinator
When I first began teaching in the public schools I was introduced to a time-honored ritual that every public school teachers knows: taking the papers for a ride. I would collect papers from students—quizzes, essays, homework—clip or band them together, drop them into the briefcase or backpack, and them take them to the car when school was dismissed. I’d take the papers for a ride home, where they often sat undisturbed in the briefcase or backpack. Sometimes they made it to the coffee table or the desk in the study; most times they just went back and forth, accumulating more and more miles like a frequent flyer does.
I have gone paperless, thanks to Moodle. I no longer take papers for a ride.
My move to paperless courses has its origins in my work as a distance education professor at another university. There, I taught masters and doctoral students in courses in curriculum, curriculum planning and instructional design. These students communicated with me via Blackboard through chats, discussion boards, electronic journals, uploaded papers and assignments and email. Since my students were physically scattered all over the world (I had Department of Defense teachers in Osaka, Japan, Peace Corps members in west Africa, and public school teachers in Atlanta, Georgia as well as students at the university who were taking both face-to-face and distance classes.) the medium of connection was electronic, not face-to-face interchanges or even paper presentations of their work.
During this time I came to depend on direct responses to student work, often using a variety of editing functions on various word processing programs to make comments on papers and projects in their draft stages as well as final submissions. Students used email and email attachments regularly but as time progressed I found that Blackboard, with its file submission function, provided a much easier avenue for responding to student work as well as storing completed items.
I also came to appreciate my students’ perspectives about distance education and finding materials on the course Blackboard site. I was constantly reminded to “put it up there” in relation to a link, a JSTOR article url, or detailed instructions.
When I came to DePauw I brought these distance education insights to my work with face-to-face classrooms using Blackboard. In the literature these classes are known as “hybrids”. As the campus made the transition to Moodle and discovered its amazing flexibility I began to consider how to make the leap to a totally paperless class. My efforts to move in this direction were significantly enhanced by the use of a Tablet PC that allowed me to use digital ink to mark student papers electronically in the same fashion that I would if I had paper copies.
My efforts then began to focus on the use of the Moodle feature “advance uploading of files”. This provided my students with the ability to upload multiple drafts of a course assignment. I could comment on multiple drafts as well as a final submission using the Tablet PC and digital ink and send the assignment back to the student, all the while maintaining a copy of the draft and the comments I had made. If I conference with a student, in a W competency for example, I could open both the students original work from Moodle and the draft containing my comments for review. New comments or additions can be added directly to a new draft that can be placed on Moodle at the conclusion of the conference.
I had always used discussion boards on Blackboard so I continued to use forums on Moodle and my students profited from this form of communication and the feedback I could provide to them. The same has proved true with the use of the journal function in Moodle.
If you examine my course Moodle site you will find a wide range of information and assignments on each course site. I continue to remind myself of my distance education insight of “put it up there” and I continue to be additive with my postings. This semester, in a W competency class with weekly journal submissions, I have been using paintings and photographs as visual prompts for their journal. Each week I post a range of visuals that student can use as fodder for their journal.
I also post a range of optional information for students in each course. Some of these posts are of readings that parallel our current assignment. Others are suggestions for books or articles by authors that students have read in other courses but which touch on our work. As well, I post student presentations for the class to view and respond to.
My classroom instruction incorporates Moodle as a supportive element along with required texts and activities. This semester I am using a standard instructional classroom with desktop computer and projector. If I am working with a word processing program then I have the additional option of plugging in my tablet pc and using digital ink to illustrate particular points. I am also working in a seminar room that does not have a projection system but students, with their individual laptops, have access to the Moodle site individually.
So in the final analysis I use Moodle and the range of opportunities that it provides but I don’t print items and bring to class and I don’t ask students to do so. My students tell me that two things emerge from this stance: they always have access to everything; they don’t worry about losing anything. My students who travel as representatives of the university are particularly appreciative of the paper-less focus and the extensive Moodle site.
If you want to move to a paperless class, regardless of whether it is a “green issue” for you or you are just tired of “taking the papers for a ride”, I suggest that you proceed with a plan such as outlined below:
- Explore the “advanced uploading of files” and go “paperless” for one assignment that has multiple drafts or submissions; assess how this works both for you and your students.
- Try the journal element of Moodle as a continuing activity over the course of a semester. You might even want to split the class into paper journals and paperless journals and compare the two (including how much paper students used with traditional paper journals).
- Try a Tablet PC to see how you might use the digital ink feature in both your teaching and your grading. Try the use of the tablet and digital ink with a face-to-face conference to see what impact this has upon students.
- Keep a record or file of the paper you distribute to your classes for a semester. Are there items that would be difficult to provide on Moodle or are they traditional offerings such as journal articles and word processed documents.
- Talk with individuals who have gone paperless in your department or among your teaching colleagues. Further, talk with the FITS staff about how you might approach this goal.
I don’t take my papers for a ride anymore but I have access to them wherever I am.
